Disclosure: This post contains paid affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
If you’ve been eyeing Rothy’s shoes and wondering if they’re really worth the hype, you’re in the right place. Consider this your go-to Rothy’s review.
I own several pairs myself and have worn them everywhere, from everyday errands to special occasions, so this is my true and honest review based on real-life wear.
I prefer to wear my Rothy’s with socks, but you can wear them either way. If you wear them with socks, choose a pair that looks somewhat nice and stylish, like these with the ruffle edges. You could also opt for no-show socks.
From sizing tips to arch support, outfit ideas, and how they actually hold up over a long time, I’m sharing everything I wish I knew before my first Rothy’s purchase.
YOU MAY ALSO ENJOY: My Honest Tuckernuck Dress Review or The Tilly Upholstered Bed Ultimate Review
The Ultimate Guide to Rothy’s Shoes
I have two pairs of Rothy’s clogs, and I am considering a third because they are just that good. They are seriously becoming one of my favorite women’s shoe brands.
I have the casual clogs in butternut and the cozy clogs in honeybun boucle. Both pairs of shoes can be worn outside, but I like to wear the cozy clogs around the house!
The casual clog has quickly become my favorite everyday shoe in the fall and winter.
I wear them with everything from sweatpants and leggings to different styles and washes of jeans. I haven’t worn them in the summer yet, but they would be cute with a short-sleeve matching set or jean shorts.
This guide will help you find your perfect pair of Rothy’s to style year-round!
Should I Size Up or Down for Rothy’s?
Sizing is the biggest question when it comes to Rothy’s shoes. After all, you do want the perfect fit when investing in a high-priced pair of shoes.
In my experience, Rothy’s typically run slightly large (especially when it comes to the cozy clog style). If you are between sizes (or a half size), I recommend going down a shoe size for a better fit.
Those with wide feet may be able to stick with their normal size, while anyone with narrow feet will appreciate the snugger fit that sizing down provides.
Rothy’s customer service is also excellent if you need to exchange for a different size. The free shipping and free returns policy make trying them at home a low risk.
My first pair of Rothy’s taught me quickly that getting the right fit is important. Don’t be afraid to order two sizes if you’re unsure. You can always return one.
Do Rothy’s Have Good Arch Support?
This is one of the most frequently asked questions, especially for those with high arches.
The classic clogs feature a comfortable, contoured EverDreamy Footbed™ with added arch support. (This is directly from the product listing!)
For everyday day wear, I find they have enough support to get me through errands, working from home, and lounging. You probably wouldn’t wear these on long walks, or if you stand all day, but for anything else, they are great!
YOU MAY ALSO ENJOY: The Ultimate Review & Guide to Veja Sneakers
They are not orthopedic shoes, but they are far more supportive than basic flats. Overall, they are very comfortable and supportive shoes.
How Long Does it Take to Break in Rothy’s?
One of my favorite things about the Rothy’s clogs is that there is no break-in period at all.
Seriously, they are comfortable from the very first wear. Unlike traditional clogs that can feel stiff, heavy, or rub, these are soft, flexible, and easy right out of the box.
The knit material and cushioned insole make them feel broken-in immediately.
If you’ve ever avoided clogs because they usually need time to “warm up” to your feet, this is good news. Rothy’s clogs are truly slip-on, comfy, and ready to go from day one!
How to Wash Rothy’s Clogs
The absolute best part about Rothy’s is that they are machine washable.
I’ve already washed my casual clogs after stepping in dog poop. I was devastated because I had just gotten them and was worried they wouldn’t clean up, but they look brand new again.
Washing them was super simple. The soles aren’t removable, so you toss them in the wash with cold water and let them air dry.
I put some paper towels inside mine to help dry them out faster. They came out perfectly!
Are Rothy’s Really Worth It?
Let’s talk about the price tag. Rothy’s definitely fall into a higher price point compared to basic shoes, but in my opinion, they are worth it for the quality, comfort, and sustainability factor.
These are high-quality, well-made shoes.
The fact that they are machine washable is the best part. You can literally toss them in the washing machine on a gentle cycle with cold water and a delicate setting, let them air dry, and they come out looking new.
When you consider the comfort, versatility, and eco-friendly production (they seriously use recycled water bottles!), I truly believe they are a great option.
Stylish Rothy’s Outfit Ideas
At first, I was unsure how to style them with anything other than leggings or sweatpants, but now I love wearing them with jeans too.
They are the perfect addition to your coastal granddaughter capsule wardrobe.
One of my favorite things about Rothy’s is that they are easy to style. These are a few of my favorite outfit ideas to help get you started!
Chunky Sweater with Straight Leg Jeans with Gold Earrings
Straight leg or flare jeans are probably the trendiest ways to style Rothy’s clogs right now!
Gold earrings dress it up just enough. It’s simple, comfortable, and easy to throw on!
Chunky Sweater // Straight Leg Jeans // Gold Heart Earrings // Ruffle Socks // Rothy’s Clogs
Flare Leggings with a Button-up Cardigan
This is one of my go-to outfits! I wear my clogs the most with flare leggings in brown, black, and navy. The butternut color is so versatile.
The white long sleeve is one of my favorite Amazon tops for layering with cardigans, pullovers, and jackets. I have it in three colors and love the scallop detail on the sleeve!
Add a simple necklace to make this outfit idea more stylish.
Flare Leggings // White Long Sleeve // Green Cardigan Sweater // Gold Necklace // Rothy’s Clogs
Stylish Matching Set with Baseball Cap
You can’t go wrong with a matching set. It’s a quick way to look put together! This would also be the absolute perfect travel outfit idea.
These clogs are made of hemp, which is a little lighter weight than the wool material in the casual clogs.
Matching Lounge Set // Blue Baseball Cap // Gold Earrings // Canvas Tote Bag // Rothy’s Clogs
Conclusion
As someone who now owns multiple pairs of shoes from Rothy’s, I can confidently say they are some of the most comfortable shoes in my closet.
From my first time wearing them to now owning a second pair (and honestly planning my next), they’ve consistently impressed me.
If you’ve been influenced by Rothy’s ads, seen them on Meghan Markle, or spotted them all over social media, the hype is real.
At the end of the day, they’ve become a staple in my wardrobe, and I don’t think I could ever live without them now.
